White Mountain Puzzles Reviews

White Mountain Puzzles has an overall rating of 2.8 based on 29 reviews. Customer feedback on White Mountain Puzzles is mixed.

2.8/5.0

29 reviews

5 Stars

6

4 Stars

3

3 Stars

7

2 Stars

5

1 Star

8

All White Mountain Puzzles Reviews (29)
Kathleen.booth
May 31, 2026
"Pieces weren’t what I expected"
I was disappointed when I opened the box. A bunch of the pieces were already bent or starting to peel, and a few didn’t fit together cleanly at all. It was frustrating for a brand new puzzle. I was also a little confused because the email made it sound like everything was all good, but what showed up was definitely not that.
hello_mirta343
May 28, 2026
"Packed really well"
I was a little worried because I needed this to arrive in good shape and felt kind of pressured about it, but the box showed up looking neat with no dents or busted corners.
hello_charles999
May 26, 2026
"Nice picture, but the puzzle felt poorly cut"
The image on the puzzle was really nice, but the actual cuts were sloppy. A bunch of pieces were stuck together, and a few seemed to fit in places they definitely shouldn’t have, which made the whole thing frustrating. I also kind of felt like just another ticket number when trying to deal with it, not like anyone was really looking into the issue
anne-Elliott
May 25, 2026
"I really do like the puzzles..."
I really do like the puzzles, and that’s what kept me browsing, but the website itself felt kind of clunky to use. Some pages loaded slower than I expected, and the filters didn’t always seem to narrow things down the way I thought they would. I was wondering if other people had the same issue or if it was just me.

The cart was probably the most frustrating part. I had to keep going back to double-check what I’d actually added because it wasn’t super obvious, and I didn’t want to accidentally order the wrong thing. I usually rely on other shoppers’ feedback for stuff like this, so I was curious whether anyone else found the cart a little confusing too.

Checkout did work in the end, so it wasn’t a total disaster, but it took more clicking around than it should have. I’d still consider ordering again because the puzzles are good, but I’d feel better if the site were smoother and a bit easier to follow
Luis_hill84
May 15, 2026
"I was hoping for more variety, but it..."
I was hoping for more variety, but it feels like the same old puzzle choices keep coming back. After a while it gets stale. It also gives me the impression they’re more focused on squeezing money out of people than actually adding fresh content.
robert1978
May 13, 2026
"Nice puzzles, but wow, that shipping"
I really liked the puzzle selection, and the site was easy to use, so no complaints there. My order showed up in good shape too, which is always nice. But the shipping cost was higher than I expected and made the total feel a little ridiculous. Because apparently getting puzzles to my door requires funding a small expedition. I’d probably order again if there’s a sale or a cheaper shipping option.
rhonda1996
May 13, 2026
"Not really my style"
i mean, the puzzle itself was fine, but I just couldn’t get into the artwork. A lot of the designs felt kind of busy, old-fashioned, and a little cheesy to me. I was hoping for something I’d actually want to frame when I finished it, but none of them really felt modern or pretty. I’m sure some people might like the style, but it was a letdown for me
AlexandraGimenez
April 11, 2026
"I accidentally ordered the wrong puzzle and..."
I accidentally ordered the wrong puzzle and had to send it back. i was expecting it to be a bit of a headache, but it was really straightforward. The reply came quickly, and the tone was friendly enough that it didn’t feel like I was dealing with some cold, automated process. My refund also showed up faster than I thought it would. Overall, I felt good about how they handled it
ValerieDeubner_35
April 09, 2026
"Box arrived in great shape"
I grabbed this after seeing a few other people mention the quality, and mine showed up just as expected. The box feels sturdy, arrived clean, and there were no dents or crushed corners
hello_tommy281
April 07, 2026
"Replacement process was more trouble than it was worth"
I ordered a puzzle and ended up having an issue with the pieces. I figured getting a replacement would be simple, but the policy felt strict, maybe unnecessarily so. It’s frustrating to pay for something and then feel like you have to prove everything and jump through a bunch of steps just to get it fixed. Customer service didn’t really make the process smoother either. I usually enjoy puzzles, but this experience left a bad impression. I’m not saying I’d never order again, but i probably wouldn’t
Eloise.slaton
April 07, 2026
"The prices were fair, and the sales..."
The prices were fair, and the sales definitely made a big difference. I’m glad I ordered, but I do kind of wish the shipping had been quicker because that part took away from the experience a bit...
hello_craig086
April 04, 2026
"Barely Any Puzzle Dust, Which Was Nice"
I was pleasantly surprised by how clean the pieces were. There was hardly any puzzle dust in the box, which I really appreciate because I usually end up wiping down the table afterward. Not a huge thing, but it makes the whole puzzle feel a little nicer to start. Also, unrelated, but I was doing this with a cup of coffee nearby and was very glad there wasn’t dust floating around everywhere.
beverly_Mclaughlin00
April 01, 2026
"Had a feeling it’d be okay, just took a bit"
Ordering was straightforward and checkout didn’t give me any trouble. I did kind of get the feeling things were moving a little slower than expected, especially since the shipping updates came in later than I would’ve liked. Overall it went fine, just not super quick.
kathy_Hooper77
March 30, 2026
"Deals was okay, but not the best"
I got a small discount code, which was nice, but the sales wasn’t really that impressive. By the time shipping got added, it kind of eat up most of the savings for me.
martha_Lombardo78
March 26, 2026
"The pieces were just too loose"
I’m not trying to be overly picky, but the pieces fit way too loosely for me. They kept lifting up and sliding around, and a few even seemed like they could fit where they didn’t actually belong. I know puzzles aren’t always perfect, but this one took the fun out of it.
NoraKent
March 25, 2026
"I bought this thinking it would be a..."
I bought this thinking it would be a easy puzzle, but it felt way harder than expected. A lot of the pieces looked super similar, so it got frustrating fast. I usually enjoy puzzles, but this one just wasn’t that fun for me.
gilbert-Shea
March 24, 2026
"This brought back some nice old memories..."
This brought back some nice old memories for me. I kind of expected the puzzle quality to be a bit hit or miss, and that was pretty much the case. It was still enjoyable overall, just not perfect.
Joe.sebastian
March 20, 2026
"Fun puzzles, but I figured the price might be lower"
I assumed these would be a little cheaper at first, but the puzzles were actually good and kept me entertained. Overall, the value was okay, just a bit on the pricey side for what you get.
HarryStepro
March 19, 2026
"Really enjoyed this one"
Finished my White Mountain puzzle and had a great time. Pieces fit well. The image was fun without being too easy.
It took a few evenings. Kinda perfect. I was a little bummed when it was done. I’d buy another.
KellyPotter
March 08, 2026
"Fun puzzle, but seriously, missing pieces?!"
The puzzle looked really nice and I was enjoying it at first, but when I got near the end, I realized there were 2 pieces missing?! After spending all that time on it, that was so frustrating. I checked the floor, the box, everything like 10 times, and nope, they just weren’t there. Not sure I’d order another one unless they get that sorted out...

View More Reviews

Have a question about White Mountain Puzzles?

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.